Payton (a dork) is in love with Carrie (the head cheerleader) who is dating Clark (the football captain). When she realizes that Payton’s crush is likely to last until middle age, Carrie sets him up with Samantha – a dorkette who works in the local comic book store. Of course, the course of true love is never smooth, Clark’s behaving strangely and Carrie’s plans run afoul of Payton’s inability to follow the simplest of instructions. Can Carrie succeed in getting Payton together with Samantha? And what’s Clark’s secret?