Wiley Roth finds a severed human finger in his kitchen one night. Understandably freaked out, Wiley and his best friend Mitch try to figure out the mystery of the finger. A search across Los Angeles brings them in contact with psychics, ineffective police, crooked taxidermists, mysterious drugged-out neighbors, and a nine-fingered woman named Cheryl who may end up being the girl of Wiley's dreams.